| The On-Line Music Review & Information Ministry |
| Red |
|
Innocence & Instinct
[Release Date: February 10, 2009] (Essential Records)
Track Listing:
Track Listing:
 | |  | |  | |  | |  | |  | |  | |  | |  |
1.0 out of 4
2.5 out of 3
2.0 out of 2
0.8 out of 1
6.3 out of 10
Message
Music
Production
Creativity
Overall Score
| 63% D |
Compare to: maybe some Linkin Park mixed with the melodic sounds of Anberlin, and
some of the darkness and mystery of Savior Machine. Nice road trip music, lyrics a bit
vague at times, but over-all a positive message.
Red’s newest offering, Innocence and Instinct, follows closely in the footsteps of their
freshman album, End of Silence, although a bit darker, and a bit edgier. In all honesty,
the lyrics come across as mostly depressing. The melodies capture angst, heart ache,
and a desire to be saved, but don’t very clearly depict any type of salvation or hope. That’
s not to say it’s all bad, the music is catchy and at some points definitely makes you
want to scream along.
The most well known song on the album so far is the second track, “Death of me.” The
music video is available on Youtube or MySpace, and shows more clearly that the fight
inside the lyrics talk about is a fight within yourself. It brings to mind the phrase, “you
are your own worst enemy.” The first track, “Fight Inside” is based on the same theme
of “Death of me.” Both songs are about an internal struggle to do the right thing, to fight
evil that we all have lurking just under the surface. In a press release, guitarist Anthony
Armstrong said that “The song is really a regretful introspective moment, where you
realize that your own actions have led you down a path you never wanted to take. You
are the one who keeps tearing yourself down in some kind of vicious cycle that never
seems to end.”
“Mystery of You” is going to get stuck in your head if you listen to it a few times, but
that’s not a bad thing. One real positive about this song is that it is closer to talking about
God than at any other point in the album. In the lyrics, the word “You” in this song is
capitalized, intoning that the “You” they are referencing is Christ, wanting to get closer
and learn more about the mystery of God. It’s not necessarily a bad thing to be vague in
music about God and Jesus, because if what you’re trying to say is not so blatant, you’
ve got a better chance at reaching a wider audience with a message of God’s hope.
Some Christians look down on this practice, thinking of it as weak or fearful Christianity.
I disagree. There needs to be music out there that doesn’t put pressure on the listener to
convert, but invites them to freely enjoy the album, and know that Christian music does
not have to be threatening.
Coming later in the album is a cover of the song “Ordinary World,” by Duran Duran, an
80’s rock band from merry ol’ England. Turning this retro rock song into a melodic, Red
flavored ballad, Red showcases a few more of their artistic talents. Although certainly a
sound from another era, the song fits fairly seamlessly in with the rest of the album
contents.
“Take It All Away,” is the last song on the standard edition, but for the dedicated fans,
the deluxe edition includes three more songs, along with a 30 second intro in the
beginning that is supposed to set a “Dante’s ‘Inferno’” tone to start out with. The bonus
track titles include “Overtake You,” “Forever,” and “Nothing and Everything.”
Closing Thoughts:
The tone of the entire CD is very introspective, which is interesting in some ways. I’m
not sure this is the kind of music I want to be devoting myself too, because the world
we live in today encourages people to look within ourselves for answers. But the Bible
tells us the opposite, revealing that we must die to ourselves, only truly finding who we
are in a live wholly given up for Christ. Proverbs 3:5 cautions us to “lean not unto your
own understanding,” and acknowledge God in everything. It seems like this album is
more about self than God, but internal struggles are a part of life, and this music may
give everyone something they can relate too.
some of the darkness and mystery of Savior Machine. Nice road trip music, lyrics a bit
vague at times, but over-all a positive message.
Red’s newest offering, Innocence and Instinct, follows closely in the footsteps of their
freshman album, End of Silence, although a bit darker, and a bit edgier. In all honesty,
the lyrics come across as mostly depressing. The melodies capture angst, heart ache,
and a desire to be saved, but don’t very clearly depict any type of salvation or hope. That’
s not to say it’s all bad, the music is catchy and at some points definitely makes you
want to scream along.
The most well known song on the album so far is the second track, “Death of me.” The
music video is available on Youtube or MySpace, and shows more clearly that the fight
inside the lyrics talk about is a fight within yourself. It brings to mind the phrase, “you
are your own worst enemy.” The first track, “Fight Inside” is based on the same theme
of “Death of me.” Both songs are about an internal struggle to do the right thing, to fight
evil that we all have lurking just under the surface. In a press release, guitarist Anthony
Armstrong said that “The song is really a regretful introspective moment, where you
realize that your own actions have led you down a path you never wanted to take. You
are the one who keeps tearing yourself down in some kind of vicious cycle that never
seems to end.”
“Mystery of You” is going to get stuck in your head if you listen to it a few times, but
that’s not a bad thing. One real positive about this song is that it is closer to talking about
God than at any other point in the album. In the lyrics, the word “You” in this song is
capitalized, intoning that the “You” they are referencing is Christ, wanting to get closer
and learn more about the mystery of God. It’s not necessarily a bad thing to be vague in
music about God and Jesus, because if what you’re trying to say is not so blatant, you’
ve got a better chance at reaching a wider audience with a message of God’s hope.
Some Christians look down on this practice, thinking of it as weak or fearful Christianity.
I disagree. There needs to be music out there that doesn’t put pressure on the listener to
convert, but invites them to freely enjoy the album, and know that Christian music does
not have to be threatening.
Coming later in the album is a cover of the song “Ordinary World,” by Duran Duran, an
80’s rock band from merry ol’ England. Turning this retro rock song into a melodic, Red
flavored ballad, Red showcases a few more of their artistic talents. Although certainly a
sound from another era, the song fits fairly seamlessly in with the rest of the album
contents.
“Take It All Away,” is the last song on the standard edition, but for the dedicated fans,
the deluxe edition includes three more songs, along with a 30 second intro in the
beginning that is supposed to set a “Dante’s ‘Inferno’” tone to start out with. The bonus
track titles include “Overtake You,” “Forever,” and “Nothing and Everything.”
Closing Thoughts:
The tone of the entire CD is very introspective, which is interesting in some ways. I’m
not sure this is the kind of music I want to be devoting myself too, because the world
we live in today encourages people to look within ourselves for answers. But the Bible
tells us the opposite, revealing that we must die to ourselves, only truly finding who we
are in a live wholly given up for Christ. Proverbs 3:5 cautions us to “lean not unto your
own understanding,” and acknowledge God in everything. It seems like this album is
more about self than God, but internal struggles are a part of life, and this music may
give everyone something they can relate too.
Review Written By: Liz Zelinski [liz.zelinski@christianmusicreview.org] Date Written: February 8, 2009
Review Rating
How do we rate our reviews? Click here for more information.
Additional Reviews
Main Review & Closing Thoughts
| [Album Review] |
Regular Edition
Deluxe Edition (CD/DVD)